Research

8 pages
4 views

Regaining some good in the world: What matters to persons diagnosed as depressed in primary care

of 8
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Share
Description
Research suggests that low rates of mental health service utilization are partly due to incongruence between patients’ viewpoints and the professional treatment models intended to help them. In order to shed light on this gap, this article presents
Transcript
  Research ArticleOpen Access Mental Health in Family Medicine (2017) 13: 381-388 reseach Acle  2017 Mental Health and Family Medicine Ltd  Regaining Some Good in the World: What Matters to Persons Diagnosed as Depressed in Primary Care Miraj U. Desai Yale Univesiy School of Medicine, New Haven, Conneccu, USA Frederick J. Wertz Fodham Univesiy, Bonx, New Yok, USA Larry Davidson Yale Univesiy School of Medicine, New Haven, Conneccu, USA Alison Kaasz Albe Einsein College of Medicine, Bonx, New Yok, USA Introducon “You feel condent [when] they are there to be your friend…instead of ‘open your mouth and say ahh,’…[if only] they would actually take time to understand what’s going on. A simple ‘what  brings you here’ instead of ‘what hurts’.” ~Participant The identication and effective treatment of depression in primary care settings is at the forefront of current health care reform efforts in the United States. Historically, primary care services have accounted for the highest percentage of the prescription of psychiatric medications, especially anti-depressants [1]. Yet primary care has typically lacked the appropriate mental health expertise to provide psychiatric care in an effective fashion. Through the combination of federal  parity legislation passed in 2008 and the comprehensive health care reform efforts outlined in the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), this situation may change dramatically. As a result, primary care settings may begin to experience a signicant inux of behavioral health professionals with appropriate training and expertise so that care for mental health and substance use disorders can be provided, in terms of both accessibility and effectiveness, on par with all other medical care [2,3]. Research suggests numerous challenges await the task of providing effective behavioral health treatment in primary care for depression, including low help-seeking rates, lack of adequate care, and mental health treatment drop out [4-6]; c.f., [7]. Studies indicate, for example, that roughly only a third to half of individuals with depression actually seek treatment [5,6], with members of ethnic minority groups doing so less than their majority group counterparts [6]. Epidemiological studies have found that roughly half of individuals with a 12-month episode of major depressive disorder received treatment, but only about 40% of these individuals actually received adequate care [8]. Finally, Edlund and colleagues found that a fth of patients in the United States leave mental health treatment early [4], with another study showing these rates to be highest—around a third—in general medical settings [9]. Treatment dropout is of course a longstanding and pervasive problem overall in the mental health eld, with some studies on psychotherapy attrition suggesting rates close to 50% [10]. Overall, research suggests that merely offering the care on-site within primary care settings may not be enough to ensure that persons with mental health  problems accept, engage, and complete treatment. There is evidence that a central reason for this apparent disconnect between the presence of behavioral health issues and the reception of effective care may be the disparate ways in which patients and professionals construe distress and depression [11-21]. For instance, Yeung et al. found signicant gaps between patients and the health care system in their study of depression in a primary care clinic in a predominately Chinese American community [15]. Of the srcinal 40 patients screened for depression, 19 had records documenting primary care ABStrACt Research suggests that low rates of mental health service utilization are partly due to incongruence between patients’ viewpoints and the professional treatment models intended to help them. In order to shed light on this gap, this article presents the second in a series examining patients’ own perspectives on experiences that would be seen as indicators of clinical depression and treatment need. For those who screened positive for depression, possibilities for practical action varied and did not necessarily include seeking clinical help. Some participants no longer screened positive for depression one month later, in large part due to their own efforts in revising their central life aims and commitments. We discuss the implications of these ndings for policy, practice, and community engagement, such as the importance of harmonizing professional care with  patients’ main commitments in life—their unattained goals and efforts to regain a sense of direction in their lives—as situated in complex community contexts. This, in effect, would reverse the direction of “adherence.” MeSh Headings/Keywords:  Depression; Primary care; Phenomenology  Miraj U. Desai, Frederick J. Wertz, Larry Davidson, Alison Karasz 382  physician involvement at the three month follow-up, but only six of these patients accepted mental health treatment. Reasons offered by the 13 patients who declined mental health referrals included: “‘trying to handle the illness by myself,’ ‘do not think that it is an illness,’ and ‘concerns that condentiality could be  breeched’” [15]. Other research suggests that when patients were placed in a treatment that was “congruent” with their own understanding of their predicament, they were more likely to engage in care than patients whose treatment did not match their own understanding [22]. Evidently it is crucial that the physician and patient connect interpersonally and share an understanding of the situation that will guide helpful collaboration.This push towards more synergy and mutual understanding aligns with the growing international person-centered medicine movement. This movement places priority on the whole person, the unique circumstances of each case, and a broader focus on health rather than only a focus on disease [23]. Mezzich and colleagues identify important constituents of the totality of health that have previously not factored centrally into health care, including a person’s social context, life projects, and values. In general, this approach demonstrates concern for the wellness of the person, the provider, and the surrounding world in which they both live.Given the anticipated increase in the identication and treatment of behavioural health conditions in primary care settings, the challenge of engaging those who need services, and the growing evidence of divergent perspectives between patients and professionals, more research is needed about patients’ views of those experiences that health care professionals identify as indicators of depression and treatment need during a routine medical visit. We could nd no study that investigated this issue  based directly on the experiences of individuals who have been identied in a primary care setting as having a clinical depression for which treatment is judged relevant. A main limitation with  past literature that examines patients’ points of view is that it  presupposes the singular validity of a Western biomedical construct of depression. But presupposing the existence of such a condition as “depression” prohibits researchers from exploring  patients’ own perspectives in their own terms, particularly among culturally diverse individuals. c.f., [24]. Although  patients’ views of their own experiences may not be relevant to traditional diagnosis, etiology, and intervention research, they are of considerable practical importance in helping providers to understand whether and why such people will seek or follow through with clinical care.The present study involved seven participants who were seeking help with medical concerns in a primary care clinic and who also screened positive for depression during their visit. This population allowed for a glimpse into the world of the non-engaged, affording the opportunity to explore persons’ experiences at the point of contact with services or referrals for mental health. The current article focusing on practice-oriented considerations is the second in a two-part series of articles whose aim is to explore the experiences that give rise to a positive depression screen and to understand what they mean to the patients themselves. The main ndings of the rst article [25] were that: the experiences to which the screen referred were characterized by a life situation in which participants were falling away from their most cherished life commitments and goals. Their experiential focus was not on ‘symptoms’ of a biomedical condition but rather on questions involving the world, particularly what was to become of them in the future with regard to the fullment or failure to full specic life-purposes. Examples included a recently failed intimate relationship and a two-year period of unemployment accompanied by a loss of esteem in the eyes of family. What ensued for participants was a downward spiral in the realms of the emotions, body, time, space, self-worth, and interpersonal relations--and edgling attempts to overcome the experience of failure and collapse, to restore positive goals and a valued place in the world. The present article now delves into the latter possibilities for overcoming the devalued situation and downward fall that generated a positive depression screen. This may shed more light on the experiences of people being screened for depression in primary care who are not yet engaged with mental health care, as well as pointing to possible points of collaboration and enhanced connection  between patient and provider as both seek ways of ameliorating the person’s distress. Methods This study utilized a qualitative method to elicit and analyze  participants’ narratives regarding the matters that led to a diagnosis of depression, described in detail elsewhere [25]; (see also the larger study in which the present one was conducted [18]). Briey, participants consisted of seven persons entering a  primary care clinic for medical concerns, and meeting positive criteria for depression according to the PHQ-9 (minimum of “other depression”) [26]. Participants were asked to describe the experiences and life contexts that underpinned each response on the depression screen. We utilized data from two points in time, which was useful in examining how persons who did not engage or complete treatment were attempting to come to terms with the matters they reported in connection with the positive depression screen. The comprehensive narratives were analyzed via the procedures of phenomenological psychological analysis to determine the meaning, context, and general structure of these experiences from the participants’ own perspective [27,28]. The study received IRB approval from both Fordham University and the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and all participants were ensured of the condentiality of their responses and signed informed consent forms. Results Struggling to Transcend: Praccal Opons and Acons in Response to the Devalued Situaon Participants’ main concerns stemmed from their challenges in meeting the most central goals and commitments of their lives, as embedded in worldly contexts. This was the stuff of life in the real, changing world: unemployment, ongoing relationship and custody struggles, physical health issues, and profound discouragement in a public service career. One  person struggled with the constriction of her life, freedom, and work in the aftermath of sudden panic attacks (and fears about their return). As goals faded for these individuals, their action, energy, and lived world, now without meaningful direction or  purpose, began to constrict as well. A characteristic sense of  regaining Some Good in he Wold: Wha Maes o Pesons Diagnosed as Depessed in Pimay Cae  383 hopelessness, sadness, immobility, passivity, self-devaluation, and alienation arose in the face of these problematic situations and thwarted goals, which remained their primary concern. It is important to emphasize here that it was their situations that concerned them primarily, and if they were concerned about their internal experience or mental life as such, these were of secondary concern. As one participant stated, “This will continue until I get a job. [With a job,] I’ll be focused and clear my head.”There was, as alluded to in the quote above, a possibility for positive transformation of their devalued situation. That is, these troubling situations in life, work, and the community were not nished or resolved but contained within them possibilities for agency and action that engaged the person in an effort to overturn them. Successful efforts, as evidenced by the person no longer screening positive for depression during the one-month follow-up interview, included one participant changing her srcinal goals after her self-perceived failures at work and social change (“I’m very small in this picture and there’s not much I can do. Do the best I can and get a tiny bit out of it”) and another re-establishing reciprocal relationship with afrming others after a failed relationship (“I speak to my friends and they listen to me and give me advice, and it helps me in a way [because] I let out everything I have inside”). These instances revealed the  possibility of re-awakening their own agency through practical action directed at their life situations, as well as renewing their sense of belonging with others. Here, changing the situation or their perspective on the situation was the primary source of change, rather than traditional behavioural health treatment. Other attempts at practical action are detailed next, including the role of the screening items and other persons, followed by an outline of the ingredients of successful professional interactions. Screening Items as Referring to Fledgling Aempts to Overcome the Devalued Situaon Some of the screening items themselves referred to edgling attempts to regain a sense of gratication in the world, to focus on a new “good.” One major example of this constituent was the experience of eating. For instance, four participants reported overeating to give themselves a new gratifying aim and overcome feelings of sadness. In each of these cases, although the initial meaning of eating was pleasure and restoration of satisfaction in life, its eventual signicance, given the bodily shame that accompanied overeating, was negative and led to their devaluing themselves rather than regaining a positive value in life. After being abandoned by a signicant other, one  participant found herself craving sweetness: “Since I have this relationship ended, I noticed I eat a lot. I wasn’t the type of  person who eat a lot and crave for sweetness. Well I let myself down because I never got this big.” Another participant dealing with a challenging work situation stated, “I would normally eat right after work to feel better. It [was] like my only form of happiness in a way.”Several also described constantly thinking and ruminating about their issues, to the point of insomnia, whether it be a  betrayal in a relationship, the loss of companionship, or chronic unemployment. This process, while not necessarily leading to  productive solutions, indeed reected how engrossed people were in dealing with or addressing their life situation. The  participant above who was facing relational abandonment stated she had sensed her signicant other’s initial betrayals and lies in her dreams, but that these dreams—however helpful—and additional ruminations disrupted her sleep: Whatever he [was] hiding, I nd it. In my dream, I nd out. The drugs, the phone calls, when he go out on certain days. When I dreamed it, it came true? That’s how I knew. It would wake me up, on top of getting overheated. I feel tired because I don’t get any sleep. I have hot ashes too so it makes it worse…And just thinking about everything that’s happening. Seeking Belonging with Non-Alienang Others and Insisng on Respect and Understanding Persons’ primary goals were deeply social in nature: to be with a genuine life-partner, be in the company of good friends, secure a valued role in the social world, and work towards social change. In the context of the failure to realize these goals,  participants felt incapable, worthless, and devalued. Others exacerbated this sense of devaluation when not attuned to the challenges the persons faced in their situations. Individuals could attempt to transcend devaluation in the context of others by insisting on being treated with more respect and understanding in relation to their situation. One participant rejected her sister’s insensitivity by insisting on her own dignity and worthiness:My sister thinks [my unemployment is] funny. I don’t think so. Treat me like a human being… She should treat me like a real person and not a kid; like a mature person, not a stranger, if you care about me like a sister. Her assertion of self-worth was an effort to re-establish a “good” kind of relationship, in which she felt valued and supported (unlike how she felt in relation to employers), and indeed one that would better serve her efforts to land a job. Another participant longed for greater concern from others regarding the importance of tackling social justice issues, which formed the basis of her life goals and her own public interest work: Why can’t they see that I really care about this? They  perceive my intensity and passion as going off the deep end. And I want to say, you need to stop chilling out! You need to be less nonchalant about things and that’s why there are so many  problems out there.When faced with unsupportive relationships, some opted to go it alone in the hopes of enhancing their situation and value. The individual dealing with chronic unemployment and unsupportive family and friends went the solo route in her quest for enjoyment and meaningful activity, which even made her appreciate aspects of her current situation: “She works all the time. I at least have fun. Playing slot machines! Life is too short and you need to have fun.” Another participant wanted a life surrounded by others she loved and valued but had given up due to the loss of a relationship decades ago. Now, coupled with numerous physical issues and the loss of her mother, she often remained alone (with important exceptions being when she was able to visit her mother in the cemetery and, as will be discussed  below, attend a senior center). However, aside from the company  Miraj U. Desai, Frederick J. Wertz, Larry Davidson, Alison Karasz 384 of television, solitude left her further isolated from others and without the moments of revitalization they might provide. Spirituality was central for some in reconnecting with others. The participant above reconnected spiritually with loved ones she had lost: “That’s why I put those pictures up. I have lots of others’ pictures there too, ex-boyfriends, nephew. I talk to my mother. Spiritually. It really does [help].” One participant who struggled with a gradual life collapse (less socializing, leaving an enjoyable job and being stuck in a boring one), pervasive fears of panic attacks, and stigma regarding both, found she was able to reframe her situation and efforts to overcome it with the help of spirituality. Specically, she hoped to serve as an inspiration for others one day: “I think I have fallen back on my spiritual side. And thinking about humanity and making it better for the next generation. To make it a little bit more acceptable for them.” Both of these participants beneted from professional guidance—one before and another after the rst screen (which she sought independently and not as a suggestion during her visit). We will now delve into the nature of such collaborations with health care professionals. Successful, Unsuccessful, and Paral Collaboraons in Primary Care: The Role of the Other in Overcoming the Devalued Situaon As stated above, participants desired supportive relationships with people with whom they could travel through life and rely upon in tough times. These types of supportive others respected and understood their goals and values, and could be helpful in moving through their current obstacles. A helpful rather than alienating relation emerged when others’ contributions and advice were trustworthy, relevant to the patients’ meaningful  pursuits, and aligned with their efforts to transcend their current situation. Sometimes, these trusted others could even  perceive needs and reveal possibilities that the person had not realized or considered. Social institutions could serve this advisory function within the patients’ practical eld of action. In general, the operative principle of successful collaborations in primary care specically was a t with patients’ desires and goals. Unsuccessful collaborations, on the other hand, were characterized by the lack of such a t. Finally, a partial collaboration was characterized by attendance to only isolated aspects of the overall quest to restore the good and reverse the collapse. Examples of unsuccessful, successful, and partial collaborations in primary care are described next. Unsuccessful collaborations:  The following illustrates the meaning of unsuccessful collaboration, in which individuals experienced the doctor’s advice and treatment recommendations as disconnected from their valued commitments. One participant experienced her physician’s advice as incongruent with her goals of producing social change, having a leadership role in  public service, and garnering the appreciation of her family through her independent efforts. She felt that the advice did not really take her goals—and their importance to her—seriously, and instead offered what she viewed as impersonal suggestions and care:Researcher: Did your doctor counsel you or give you advice during the visit? If so, what did he say? Participant: Not really. About my job—He said you either quit, have a meltdown, or take medication. And I was like “great” (sarcastic tone). It was helpful in that it’s nice to know that I could take something that might make me feel better. My friends have said “take it, take it” but I can’t bring myself to do it. I don’t want to become addicted, it could change the way I act. Anti-anxiety and anti-depression medications have bad stigmas. I don’t like that how after 20 minutes in a doctor’s ofce that you can prescribe something without really knowing me. While acknowledging they may make her feel better, medication went against her desire for autonomy, self-efcacy, and individuation from her mother and sister (who were both taking anti-depressant medication). This participant was  prescribed anti-anxiety and anti-depressant medications, but only lled the former because of insurance restrictions. She took one dose and said it was “working” and “kind of enjoyed it” but discontinued it precisely for those reasons. She not only feared addiction, which would push her further away from her goals, but there was a sense that these feelings brought on by the medications were illusory and signied giving up on her commitment to confront the real world. To a question pertaining to side effects, for example, she responded: “Dizziness, a serenity that is fake because you’re not in reality anymore.” During the second time point, she no longer screened positive for depression, possibly due to shifting her goals, albeit ambivalently, to what she now perceived was  possible in her public interest job:I feel relatively better…It’s a mix of things. I let things go. I came to the realization that I can’t put it all on myself. I’m very small in this picture and there’s not much I can do. Do the best I can and get a tiny bit out of it. I lowered my expectations. I’m hoping I don’t look back on that though and regret it. Successful collaborations:  Turning now to successful collaborations, one participant’s trusted physician helped address the social isolation, passivity, and self-devaluation she had been living with ever since the loss of past relationships, which were exacerbated by her debilitating physical illness. The physician specically recommended, even prior to the  positive screen, that she attend a senior center, which her family encouraged and which she eventually found to be illuminating. She described:I initially went to [the senior center] because of my doctor. I told her that I was depressed so she recommended the senior centre. She never prescribed or asked about medications or anything like that. She said I could benet from socializing and exercising more. See, I never talked about my depression to any other doctors, ever. But this doctor, I had her for a long time and felt I could tell her. She was telling me I needed to socialize and exercise more, instead of sitting at home all the time. Before, I would sit with the TV on all day and night and do nothing. At the centre, at rst, I did not want to go but my doctor, my sister, my brother, and my friend all said I should…I didn’t talk to nobody at rst but I went and liked it. It was like an opening. It was like an opening because it helped my depression. I could  be more expressive. Nothing there makes me feel depressed. The senior centre, when I’m there, it doesn’t make me think of  regaining Some Good in he Wold: Wha Maes o Pesons Diagnosed as Depessed in Pimay Cae  385 things that make me depressed…They have activities, exercises,  bingo, and computer training even.This participant’s use of the terms “depression” and “depressed” appeared to signify emotional problems (deep sadness), extreme loneliness, and living a life of profound isolation, rather than her focus being on recovering from an illness. Her trusted primary care physician was indeed deeply attuned to those social lacks in her life, came up with creative solutions, and successfully helped her regain some good company and positive movement in her life. Partial collaborations:  Finally, partial collaborations involved professional focus on isolated aspects of experience (e.g., fatigue, sleep, etc.) but did not directly address the core of persons’ life situations. One participant, who had struggled with longstanding relationship, divorce, custody, and childcare issues, had beneted from a prescription for Paxil in the past,  before the time of this study:Well my doctor told me I looked upset so I started telling him what was going on—about not sleeping and the problems in the house, being upset all the time…and he said that has to do with not sleeping. And he suggested I should go to counselling and he prescribed the Paxil.He did not go to individual therapy at the time, but eventually  participated in family therapy (through his then-wife’s counsellor) that helped “resolve some issues with the family.” This participant stated that medication only addressed certain  problems: “It just took away that anger. It didn’t change how I felt…it didn’t make me happy, didn’t make me want to cry. That uptight feeling…it just took that away.” The matter-of-fact advice from his physician, which he appreciated, spoke more directly to his situation: “the whole situation with my wife…he said [If I] can’t x it to leave it alone.” At the time of the present study, the participant continued to struggle with the care of his children, post-divorce, and remained open to treatment, but this option remained an uncertain prospect due to his commitment to, and the time demands of, parenting.Another participant’s experience of physicians was that they were useful for attending to the bodily collapse inherent in her experience, but they did not provide a pathway toward the larger life transformation she desired: “She can deal with the physical aspects of it…headaches, aches. I mentioned to her that I don’t want to be one of those individuals that is happy to take a pill.” She later consulted a psychotherapist on her own, independent of the screen and primary care visit, to resume a life where she could freely socialize with others and return to creative and engaging work, both of which were inhibited by her ongoing fears about another (public) panic episode. Psychotherapy carried the potential to reconnect her with these important life goals and also to obtain greater awareness and determinacy of how she had gotten to this place of social isolation, boring work, and lack of freedom. Discussion Many people with depression do not seek or receive treatment [5,6,8] suggesting a gap between health services and the specic populations they are designed to help. In the present study, experiences that health care professionals identify as indicators of depression and need for treatment were part of a larger backdrop of individuals feeling removed from their most valued goals, which they dened in terms of their life situations. Participants saw a number of practical options to achieve important ends and thereby get back within reach of what was lost or nd a new “good” in order to regain a sense of purpose and direction in the world. The nature of their difculties, as well as the specic doctor-patient communication process, determined whether clinical help appeared as relevant to their attempts to confront and change their current situation. Concrete Pracce Suggesons Overall, we found that at the heart of the encounter between  potential patients and the health care system is a risk of incongruence: What is pertinent to the patient may not appear related to what health care can offer; what is pertinent to the health care provider may not be communicated in terms that relate to patients’ central values and goals. The ndings suggest that one way to bridge this incongruence in primary care, as illustrated through the successful collaborations in this study, is to genuinely convey how doctors’ offerings relate to the same goals toward which persons are striving, so that health services are understood by the patient as serving these personally meaningful ends. This suggestion reverses the traditional meaning of “adherence”—rather than patients adhering to a treatment prescribed by a practitioner, services need to adhere to, or relate to, patients’ most meaningful pursuits and commitments as embedded in diverse settings. The basis of identifying individuals with depression in the current study was a commonly used depression screening checklist (PHQ-9) [29,30]. The screening criteria identied individuals who were struggling through various situations, and the current descriptive approach offers further suggestions regarding how physicians might proceed from identication to a fuller recognition of the struggle in which these individuals are engaged, as a basis for exploring opportunities for collaboration. Despite the inherent turbulence and uncertainty of patients’ situations (e.g., unemployment, lack of progress in social action efforts, a life-long lived in solitude, ongoing custody issues), there were openings for a caring other to enter into their worlds and support their attempts to address these unattained goals and stied desires. Indeed, whether others were experienced as afrming or alienating depended on their level of sensitivity to, and understanding of, the matter. Successful collaborations were determined by the relevance of the pathways offered by  physicians to patients’ aims, whereas unsuccessful ones were determined by experiences of the lack of relevance. A person struggling with decades of social isolation in the aftermath of loss beneted from attending a community centre on the advice of her trusted doctor and encouragement of family and friends. A person struggling with social justice goals and confronting  problematic social conditions saw medication as irrelevant to, if not obstructing, these goals. This latter case demonstrated the unintended outcome on the part of someone who was trying to help but whose advice was seen as too narrow and not addressing the person’s fundamental concerns.
Related Documents
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks