Shopping

17 pages
220 views

Hobson’s choice: The effects of research evaluation on academics’ writing practices in England.

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 17
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Share
Description
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to examine the influence of research evaluation policies and their interpretation on academics’ writing practices in three different higher education institutions and across three different disciplines.
Transcript
  !" $% &'(%) *+, !"#$%%&"'( *+ ,-./01+   2&34&564 "'&7"89 :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 E5C%>5@+  !"#$% '()*+,# (- .+-(*/,0$(+ 1,+,23/3+0  ( FG,H1( DD+/I/J+ KLM /.+//.NOPQM!I/-I-./FI.-/F " !'(-%,  2&34&564 "'&7"89 :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 E5C%>5@+  ./(0"1,  !"#$%%&"'( *'>=&5 2"/13*-,  P4%73 Q&$=5>% &; M5;&=A><7&5 !>5>C8A85< 4%56"1)+,  P">@8A7" B=7<75CR S5&B%8@C8 "=8><7&5R =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5R 8D74<8A&%&CTR UEV  .$+(1*&( W$=D&48 X :'8 D$=D&48 &; <'74 D>D8= 74 <& 8Y>A758 <'8 75;%$85"8 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 D&%7"784 >5@ <'87= 75<8=D=8<><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 <'=88 @7;;8=85< '7C'8= 8@$"><7&5 754<7<$<7&54 >5@ >"=&44 <'=88 @7;;8=85< @74"7D%7584+ *D8"7;7">%%T( <'8 D>D8= @74"$4484 '&B E5C%>5@64 5><7&5>% =848>="' 8Y"8%%85"8 ;=>A8B&=S ,UEV1 >5@ 754<7<$<7&5>% =84D&5484 <& 7< 4'>D8 <'8 @8"747&54 >">@8A7"4 A>S8 >3&$< <'87= B=7<75C+ K847C5OA8<'&@O>DD=&>"' X JG >">@8A7"4 >< <'=88 E5C%74' $57?8=47<784 B8=8 75<8=?78B8@+ :'8 >">@8A7"4 B8=8 ;=&A &58 *:E! @74"7D%758 ,A><'8A><7"41( &58 '$A>57<784 @74"7D%758 ,'74<&=T1 >5@ &58 >DD%78@ @74"7D%758 ,A>=S8<75C1+ U8D8><8@ 48A7I4<=$"<$=8@ 75<8=?78B4 ;&"$48@ &5 @7;;8=85< >4D8"<4 &; >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84+ 28>@4 &; @8D>=<A85<4 >5@ >@A7574<=><7?8 4<>;; B8=8 >%4& 75<8=?78B8@+ K><> B>4 "&@8@ $475C <'8 Z$>%7<><7?8 @><> >5>%T474 4&;<B>=8( P<%>4+<7+ V75@75C4 X P">@8A7"46 >37%7<T <& 4$""88@ 75 <'87= ">=88= B>4 "%&48%T <78@ <& <'87= >37%7<T <& A88< Z$>5<7<><7?8 >5@ Z$>%7<><7?8 <>=C8<4 @=7?85 3T =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4( 3$< <'848 B8=8 D=8@7"><8@ &5 >5 $5=8>%74<7" $5@8=4<>5@75C &; S5&B%8@C8 "=8><7&5+ U848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 %7A7<8@ <'8 8D74<8A7" "'&7"84 >?>7%>3%8 <& >">@8A7"4( D>=<%T 38">$48 <'8T D$4'8@ >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C <&B>=@4 C85=84 >5@ D$3%7"><7&5 ?85$84 <'>< "&5;%7"<8@ B7<' @74"7D%75>=T <=>@7<7&54 >5@ D>=<%T 38">$48 <'8T B8=8 8?85%T @74<=73$<8@ >"=&44 754<7<$<7&54 >5@ >C8 C=&$D4+ L=7C75>%7<TO?>%$8 X :'74 B&=S ;7%%4 > C>D 75 <'8 %7<8=><$=8 3T &;;8=75C 8AD7=7">% >5@ Z$>%7<><7?8 ;75@75C4 &5 <'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 75 "&5<8Y<+ M< 74 >%4& &58 &; <'8 &5%T D>D8=4 <& ;&"$4 &5 <'8 B>T4 75 B'7"' 75@7?7@$>%46 >">@8A7" B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 D>=<7"$%>= >=8 4'>D8@ 3T 4$"' 4T4<8A4+ 73(1")/&('"3 P%A&4< 8?8=T >4D8"< &; >5 >">@8A7"64 B&=S 74 A8@7><8@ 3T B=7<75C( 3&<' 75 <8=A4 &; <'8 @>TI<&I@>T <>4S4 <'>< "&54$A8 <'87= <7A8 >5@ 75 <8=A4 &; <'87= 4"'&%>=4'7D &?8= &; <'8 "&$=48 &; > ">=88=+ :'74 B=7<75C >5@ <'8 D=>"<7"84 >=&$5@ 7< >=8 "'>5C75C >4 <'8 @8A>5@4 &; >">@8A7" %7;8 '>?8 "'>5C8@+ :=>54;&=A><7&54 75 '7C'8= 8@$"><7&5( 75"%$@75C <'8 75<=&@$"<7&5 &; > A&=8 A>5>C8=7>%74< >DD=&>"'( '>?8 >%<8=8@ <'8 5><$=8 &; <'8 B=7<75C @8A>5@4 ;>"8@ 3T >">@8A7"4 ,#%>=S8 >5@ [8BA>5( /GG0R K88A 30 ,#  +( -..01+ L58 &; <'8 A&4< 47C57;7">5< &; <'848 @8A>5@4 &5 >">@8A7"4\ B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 =8%><84 <& 4T4<8A4 ;&= 8?>%$><75C =848>="' Z$>%7<T( B'7"'( 75 <'8 ]^( B'8=8 <'8 "$==85< 4<$@T 74 %&"><8@( <>S84 <'8 ;&=A &; <'8 5><7&5>% U848>="' EY"8%%85"8 V=>A8B&=S ,UEV1+ :'74 5><7&5>% 8Y8="748  !" $% &'(%) *+, !"#$%%&"'( *+ ,-./01+   2&34&564 "'&7"89 :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 E5C%>5@+  !"#$% '()*+,# (- .+-(*/,0$(+ 1,+,23/3+0 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`&$=5>%4 >5@ =8B>=@75C D$3%7"><7&5 &; >=<7"%84 75 <'848+ :'74 D>D8= >7A4 <& 8YD%&=8 <'8 B>T4 75 B'7"' 4T4<8A4 ;&= 8?>%$><75C =848>="'( 75"%$@75C <'8 UEV >5@ <'8 754<7<$<7&5>% 4<=><8C784 7< 4D>B54( 4'>D8 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 <'=88 @7;;8=85< $57?8=47<784 75 E5C%>5@+ a7<' =8;8=85"8 <& 8Y<=>"<4 ;=&A 48A7I4<=$"<$=8@ 75<8=?78B4 B7<' >">@8A7"4( 7< 74 >=C$8@ <'>< <'848 8?>%$><7&5 D&%7"784 D$< "&5;%7"<75C D=844$=84 &5 >">@8A7" B=7<75C( %7A7<75C <'8 8D74<8A7" D&47<7&54 <'8T ">5 '&%@ >5@ "'&7"84 <'8T ">5 A>S8+ 8%+%*1&0 %9*-/*('"3 *3) '(+ %::%&(+ b&<' 754<7<$<7&5>% >5@ 75@7?7@$>% =848>="' 8Y"8%%85"8 >=8 "&54<=$"<4 B'&48 A8>575C4 >=8 47<$><8@ B7<'75 <'8 4&"7>% >5@ D&%7<7">% "&5<8Y<4 75 B'7"' <'8T >=8 $48@( >5@ 3&<' <'8 5&<7&5 &; c8Y"8%%85"8d >5@ <'8 A8>54 3T B'7"' 7< 74 $48@ <& >44844 =848>="' '>?8 3885 8Y<8547?8%T "=7<7Z$8@ &5 >5 7@8&%&C7">% %8?8%+ !&&=8 30 ,#  + ,-./F1( ;&= 8Y>AD%8( '>?8 >=C$8@ <'>< 8Y"8%%85"8 75"%$@84 > "&AD>=><7?8 8%8A85<( >5@ 74 D=7A>=7%T( <'8=8;&=8( > ='8<&=7">% @8?7"8 ;&= "%>7A75C ?>%$8 >"=&44 754<7<$<7&54 >5@ @74"7D%7584 =><'8= <'>5 > A8>575C;$% B>T &; @84"=7375C <'8 75'8=85< Z$>%7<784 &; >5T C7?85 D78"8 &; B&=S+ *<=><'8=5 ,/GG0( -...1 '>4 >=C$8@ <'>< =848>="' >$@7< 4T4<8A4 <85@ <& "&5;%><8 <'8 Z$>%7<T &; =848>="' 7<48%; >5@ <'8 Z$>%7<T &; @8D>=<A85<4 &= =848>="' "85<=84+ *7A7%>=%T( a7%A&<< ,-.//1 >5@ b$==&B4 ,-./-1 >=C$8 <'>< 8?>%$><7&5 <&&%4 4$"' >4 `&$=5>% %74<4 >5@ <'8 'I75@8Y '>?8 "&A8 <& 85>"< >">@8A7" ?>%$8 75 B>T4 ;&= B'7"' <'8T B8=8 58?8= @847C58@+ EAD7=7">% =848>="' ;=&A <'8 ;78%@ &; 4"785"8 >5@ <8"'5&%&CT 4<$@784 >5@ D&%7"T 4<$@784 '>?8 <85@8@ <& <>S8 > A>"=&ID8=4D8"<7?8( %&&S75C >< <'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 >< 5><7&5>% &= 754<7<$<7&5>% %8?8%+ V&= 8Y>AD%8( > 5$A38= &; 4<$@784 '>?8 "&AD>=8@ @7;;8=85< 5><7&5>% =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 ,K8==7"S >5@ W>?&58( -./eR U8>%8 >5@ *8838=( -./eR U83&=> >5@ :$==7( -./e1 B'7%8 373%7&A8<=7" 4<$@784 '>?8 8Y>A758@ <'8 75<8=>"<7&5 38<B885 "7<><7&5 D><<8=54 >5@ =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 ;=>A8B&=S4 ,!&8@( -..HR b&=5A>55( -./e1+ P< 754<7<$<7&5>% %8?8%( E4D8%>5@ >5@ *>$@8= ,-..01 8Y>A758@ <'8 8;;8"<4 &; $57?8=47<T =>5S75C4 75 %>B 4"'&&%4 75 <'8 ]*P( B'7%8 >  !" $% &'(%) *+, !"#$%%&"'( *+ ,-./01+   2&34&564 "'&7"89 :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 E5C%>5@+  !"#$% '()*+,# (- .+-(*/,0$(+ 1,+,23/3+0  ( FG,H1( DD+/I/J+ KLM /.+//.NOPQM!I/-I-./FI.-/F $ A&=8 =8"85< 4<$@T 3T U$4';&=<' >5@ K8 U7`"S8 ,-./H1 8Y>A758@ <'8 B>T4 75 B'7"' `&$=5>% 7AD>"< ;>"<&=4 B8=8 $48@ 3T =848>="' <8>A4 75 <B& $57?8=47<T A8@7">% "85<=84 75 <'8 [8<'8=%>5@4+ L58 &; <'8 ;8B 4<$@784 <& ;&"$4 &5 >=<4 >5@ '$A>57<784 =848>="'8=4 B>4 3T 2>AA>=;8%< >5@ K8 U7`"S8 ,-./H1( B'& "&A3758@ @><> =8C>=@75C D$3%74'75C D=>"<7"84 75 *B8@85 B7<' 4$=?8T @><> ;=&A &58 >=<4 ;>"$%<T <& $5@8=4<>5@ '&B >">@8A7"4 B8=8 =84D&5@75C <& =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 D&%7"784 75 *B8@85+ P 4A>%%8= 3&@T &; %7<8=><$=8 '>4 ><<8AD<8@ <& 8Y>A758 <'8 "&54<7<$<7?8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 ;=&A <'8 3&<<&AI$D( 3T %&&S75C >< <'87= 75;%$85"8 &5 <'8 %7?84 &; 75@7?7@$>% >">@8A7"4+ _7%% ,-..G1 8Y>A758@ <'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"4\ A&<7?><7&5 >5@ B8%%3875C( B'7%8 &<'8=4 '>?8 ;&"$48@ &5 >">@8A7"4\ ><<7<$@84 <&B>=@4 8?>%$><7?8 <&&%4 4$"' >4 `&$=5>% 7AD>"< ;>"<&=4 >5@ <'8 'I75@8Y ,PS4584 >5@ U7D( -..GR b$8%>I#>4>% >5@ fT"'( -./-1+ g844 74 S5&B5( '&B8?8=( >3&$< <'8 75;%$85"8 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >"<$>% S5&B%8@C8 D=&@$"<7&5 ,!$448%75( -./e1( D>=<7"$%>=%T >< <'8 %8?8% &; 75@7?7@$>% >">@8A7"4\ %7?8@ 8YD8=785"8 >5@ B=7<75C D=>"<7"84+ L58 =8"85< 8Y"8D<7&5 74 V&"'%8= 30 ,#  + ,-./F1( B'& 75?84<7C><8@ <'8 B>T4 <'>< @&"<&=>% 4<$@85<4 >5@ 8>=%T ">=88= =848>="'8=4 75 P$4<=7> >4"=738 B&=<' <& @7;;8=85< >4D8"<4 &; <'87= B&=S  %  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`"S8( -./H1+ V75>%%T( <'8 B>T4 75 B'7"' B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 D>=<7"$%>= >=8 4'>D8@ 3T 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 '>4 =8"87?8@ ?8=T %7<<%8 ><<85<7&5( 8?85 <'&$C' B=7<75C 74 "85<=>% <& B'>< >">@8A7"4 @&+ a=7<75C 74 5&< > <=>54D>=85< A8@7$A ;&= "&AA$57"><75C 75;&=A><7&5( 3$< > '7C'%T 4&"7>% >"<7?7<T >5@ 47<8 &; 58C&<7><7&5 &; 4&A8<7A84 "&5;%7"<75C 48<4 &; D=7&=7<784 >5@ 7@85<7<784 ,:=8@8 30 ,#  +( -./-1 <'>< %78 >< <'8 '8>=< &; B'>< 7< A8>54 <& "=8><8 S5&B%8@C8+ :'74 D>D8= >7A4 <& 8YD%&=8 75@7?7@$>% >">@8A7"4\ =84D&5484 <& <'8 A$%<7D%8 @8A>5@4 &5 <'87= 4"'&%>=%T B=7<75C( 4D8"7;7">%%T '&B <'87= B=7<75C >5@ D$3%74'75C D=>"<7"84 >=8 4'>D8@ @7=8"<%T >5@ 75@7=8"<%T 3T =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 D&%7"784( >5@ '&B <'848 7AD>"< <'8 "'&7"84 <'8T A>S8 >3&$< <'87= =848>="' B=7<75C+ :'8 D>D8= @=>B4 &5 Z$>%7<><7?8 75<8=?78B @><> B7<' >">@8A7"4 75 <'8 @7;;8=85< @74"7D%7584 >< $57?8=47<784 75 E5C%>5@( "&%%8"<8@ >4 D>=< &; >5 E*U#I;$5@8@ D=&`8"< 3>48@ >< h754<7<$<8 5>A8 >5@ %&"><7&5i+ :'8 D=&`8"< 8Y>A7584 '&B S5&B%8@C8 74 D=&@$"8@ <'=&$C' >">@8A7"4\ B=7<75C D=>"<7"84( >5@ '&B <'848 >=8 4'>D8@ 3T <'8 "&5<8AD&=>=T "&5<8Y< &; '7C'8= 8@$"><7&5( 75"%$@75C A>5>C8=7>% D=>"<7"84 >5@ =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4+ V&= <'8 D$=D&484 &; <'74 4<$@T( B=7<75C 74 4885 >4 > 48< &; D=>"<7"84 <'>< >=8 8A38@@8@ 75 4&"7>% "&5<8Y<4 '74<&=7">%%T %&"><8@ 75 <7A8 >5@ 4D>"8 ,b>=<&5( -..0R 2>A7%<&5( -./-R :$4<75C( -./-1+ :'74 >DD=&>"' >"S5&B%8@C84 <'>< >">@8A7" B=7<75C 85<>7%4 B'>< j>5 g88$B85 ,-..N( D+ F1 ">%%4 c4&"7>%%T =8C$%><8@ B>T4 &; @&75C <'75C4d( >5@ 75?&%?84  !" $% &'(%) *+, !"#$%%&"'( *+ ,-./01+   2&34&564 "'&7"89 :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 E5C%>5@+  !"#$% '()*+,# (- .+-(*/,0$(+ 1,+,23/3+0  ( FG,H1( DD+/I/J+ KLM /.+//.NOPQM!I/-I-./FI.-/F & >5>%T475C 8%8A85<4 &; <'8 8?8=T@>T B=7<75C 8YD8=785"84 >5@ >"<7?7<784 &; D>=<7"7D>5<4+ :'848 75"%$@8@ <'8 =8%><7&54'7D4 >5@ "&%%>3&=><7&54 7AD%7"><8@ 75 <'87= B=7<75C( <'8 <&&%4 >5@ =84&$="84 <'8T @=8B &5( >5@ <'8 @74<=73$<7&5 &; B=7<75C >"<7?7<784 >"=&44 4D>"8 >5@ <7A8 ,g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e1( B'8=83T 75;&=A>5<4 ;=&A <'8 =848>="'8=4\ D=&;8447&5>% 58<B&=S4 B8=8 >4S8@ ;&= 4$CC84<7&54 ;&= D&<85<7>% D>=<7"7D>5<4( B'& <'85 =8"&AA85@8@ &<'8=4 ?7> <'87= D=&;8447&5>% 58<B&=S4+ M5 ">484 B'8=8 <'74 @7@ 5&< T78%@ > "&5<>"< 75 <'8 <>=C8< @74"7D%7584( >">@8A7"4 @88A8@ 4$7<>3%8 B8=8 "&5<>"<8@ @7=8"<%T ?7> <'87= 754<7<$<7&5>% B83D>C8 >5@ 75?7<8@ <& D>=<7"7D><8+ :'74 T78%@8@ > <&<>% &; N/ 75<8=?78B4( B7<' JG @7;;8=85< >">@8A7"4+ P%% D>=<7"7D>5<4 B8=8 75 =848>="'I>"<7?8 D&4<4( =>5C75C 75 4857&=7<T ;=&A %8"<$=8= <& D=&;844&=+ :'8 5>A84 &; $57?8=47<784 >5@ 75@7?7@$>%4 '>?8 3885 >5&5TA748@ >5@ 75 D=8485<75C <'8 @><>( 4&A8 7@85<7;T75C @8<>7%4 '>?8 3885 "'>5C8@+ P "&=8 C=&$D &; /F >">@8A7"4 B8=8 75<8=?78B8@ <'=88 <7A84( B7<' 8>"' 75<8=?78B ;&"$475C &5 > @7;;8=85< >4D8"< &; <'87= B=7<75C D=>"<7"84+ M5 &=@8= <& 38<<8= $5@8=4<>5@ <'8 8;;8"<4 &; A><8=7>% 4D>"8 >5@ =84&$="84 &5 <'87= S5&B%8@C8 "=8><7&5 D=>"<7"84( <'8 ;7=4< &; <'848 B>4 > cC&I>%&5Cd 75<8=?78B ,_>="7> 30 ,#  +( -./-1( 75 B'7"' D>=<7"7D>5<4 C>?8 <'8 =848>="'8=4 > ?7=<$>% >5@ D'T47">% <&$= &; <'87= B&=SD%>"8+ :'8 48"&5@( <8"'5&I37&C=>D'7">%( 75<8=?78B ,b>=<&5 >5@ g88( -./e1 ;&"$48@ &5 <'8 D>=<7"7D>5<46 $48 &; @7C7<>% <8"'5&%&C784 >< @7;;8=85< D&75<4 >5@ 75 @7;;8=85< @&A>754 &; <'87= %7?84+ V75>%%T( > c@>TI75I<'8I%7;8d 75<8=?78B ;&"$48@ &5 > 4D8"7;7" @>T 75 <'8 %7;8 &; <'8 D>=<7"7D>5<4+ :'8 =8A>7575C ee >">@8A7"4 B8=8 75<8=?78B8@ &5"8( B7<' <'8 >7A &; ?8=7;T75C ;75@75C4 ;=&A <'8 "&=8 C=&$D+ :'848 &58I&;; 75<8=?78B4 ;&"$48@ &5 <'8 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 C858=>%( 75"%$@75C <'8 C85=84 &; B=7<75C <'8T B8=8 8YD8"<8@ <& D=&@$"8( <'8 =84&$="84 <'8T @=8B &5 <& >"'78?8 <'74( >5@ <'8 A8>54 3T B'7"' <'87= B=7<75C B>4 8?>%$><8@+ M5<8=?78B4 B8=8 >%4& "&5@$"<8@ B7<' >@A7574<=><7?8 4<>;; >5@ '8>@4 &; @8D>=<A85<4 75  !" $% &'(%) *+, !"#$%%&"'( *+ ,-./01+   2&34&564 "'&7"89 :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 &5 >">@8A7"46 B=7<75C D=>"<7"84 75 E5C%>5@+  !"#$% '()*+,# (- .+-(*/,0$(+ 1,+,23/3+0  ( FG,H1( DD+/I/J+ KLM /.+//.NOPQM!I/-I-./FI.-/F ' &=@8= <& $5@8=4<>5@ '&B B=7<75C 74 4'>=8@( >%%&"><8@( "&$5<8@ >5@ 8?>%$><8@ >< @8D>=<A85<>% >5@ ;>"$%<T %8?8%+ :'8 75<8=?78B4 B8=8 =8"&=@8@ >5@ <=>54"=738@ 38;&=8 3875C >5&5TA748@ >5@ 85<8=8@ 75<& P:gP*+<7 Z$>%7<><7?8 @><> >5>%T474 4&;<B>=8 ;&= "&@75C+ :'8 "&@75C 4T4<8A B>4 $48@ <& "><8C&=748 <'8 @><> >5@ <>C >A&5C &<'8= <'75C4( 754<>5"84 75 B'7"' D>=<7"7D>5<4 <>%S8@ >3&$< @7;;8=85< C85=84 &; B=7<75C &= A8>54 &; 8?>%$><75C <'87= B&=S+ :'8 ;&"$4 75 <'74 D>D8= 74 &5 <'8 "'>75 &; 8;;8"<4 38<B885 5><7&5>% UEV ,=848>="' 8Y"8%%85"81 D&%7"784( 754<7<$<7&5>% >5@ @8D>=<A85<>% D&%7"784( >5@ 75@7?7@$>% >">@8A7"4\ B=7<75C D=>"<7"84+ 8%+/-(+ *3) )'+&/++'"3 :'8 =84$%<4 &; <'8 D=&`8"< =8?8>% <8547&54 38<B885 <'8 ;&=A4 &; S5&B%8@C8 <'>< B8=8 ?>%$8@ ;&= <'8 D$=D&484 &; <'8 5><7&5>% =848>="' 8Y"8%%85"8 ;=>A8B&=S >5@ <'&48 <'>< B8=8 ?>%$8@ 3T <'8 >">@8A7"4 <'8A48%?84+ :'848 '>@ > D&B8=;$% 75;%$85"8 &5 <'8 "'&7"84 >?>7%>3%8 <& >">@8A7"4 >3&$< B'7"' ;&=A4 &; B=7<75C <& D=7&=7<748 >5@ B'8=8 <& D$3%74' <'87= =848>="'+ :'8 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 B8=8 $58?85%T @74<=73$<8@ >"=&44 @74"7D%7584( 754<7<$<7&54 >5@ >">@8A7" >C8 C=&$D4( B7<' 7AD%7"><7&54 ;&= @74"7D%75>=T ?>%$84 >5@ ">=88= A&37%7<T+ :'8 ;&%%&B75C <'=88 48"<7&54 @74"$44 ;7=4< ;75@75C4 >3&$< <'8 "%&48 %75S 38<B885 >">@8A7"46 ">=88= 4$""844 >5@ <'8 $5@8=4<>5@75C &; S5&B%8@C8 "=8><7&5 <'>< $5@8=%784 <'8 UEV >5@ <'85 <'8 8D74<8A7" 8;;8"<4 &; =848>="' 8?>%$><7&5 4T4<8A4 75 <B& @74"7D%7584+ :'74 74 ;&%%&B8@ 3T >5 >5>%T474 &; 75<8=?78B @><> &5 <'8 8;;8"<4 &; <'8 UEV &5 B=7<75C ;&= 5&5I>">@8A7" >$@785"84+ !"##$%&'( *'+,#-."'+&'(- $/ "0"+,1&0 -*00,-- ]54$=D=7475C%T( <'74 4<$@T ;&$5@ <'>< >">@8A7"4\ "&5@7<7&54 &; D=&3><7&5 >5@ D=&A&<7&5 B8=8 <78@ <& <'87= 4"'&%>=%T B=7<75C( B'7"' 75 <$=5 B>4 $5@8=4<&&@ >%A&4< 8Y"%$47?8%T 75 <8=A4 &; <'8 UEV+ P%<'&$C' EAA> @&84 5&< 8YD%7"7<%T A85<7&5 <'8 UEV 75 '8= "&AA85< 38%&B( 4'8 @&84 8"'& 7<4 <8=A75&%&CT 75 @84"=7375C <'8 4<>5@>=@ 4'8 74 8YD8"<8@ <& A88< >4 <'=88I4<>=( B'7"'( >""&=@75C <& <'8 UEV( 74 k75<8=5><7&5>%%T 8Y"8%%85<k9 <=(1*&( > M\A &5 D=&3><7&5 >< <'8 A&A85<( > ;&$=IT8>= D=&3><7&5>=T D8=7&@+ K$=75C <'>< <7A8 M '>?8 <& D$3%74' <B& D>D8=4 >< <'=88I4<>=+ 4//,5 6370)*3* $+ /,*830$+29 :)""3## ;*()< 28>@ &; K8D>=<A85< *<8D'>578 >%4& 75?&S84 <'8 UEV B'85 >4S8@ B'>< B=7<75C 4'8 8YD8"<8@ <'8 >">@8A7" 4<>;; 75 '8= @8D>=<A85< <& 38 D=&@$"75C9 <=(1*&( ? l<'8 A757A$A <'>< B&$%@ 38 =8Z$7=8@ 74 &58 C&&@ D$3%7"><7&5 > T8>= hli 7; 4&A83&@T '>@ &58 C&&@ D$3%7"><7&5 > T8>=( <'8T B&$%@ 38 &S>T ;&= <'8 UEV hli :'8T B&$%@ D=&3>3%T 38 &S>T ;&= D=&A&<7&5 >5@ 8?8=T<'75C 8%48+ =03<>,+$35 ?3,@ (- A3<,*0/3+09 B#,03 ;#,""  P4S8@ B'>< 4'8 A8>5< 3T > mdC&&@ D$3%7"><7&5d( 4'8 <>%S8@ >3&$< 8YD8"<8@ C85=8 ,> `&$=5>% >=<7"%81( <'8 5$A38= &; >$<'&=4 ,&581 >5@ <'8 Z$>%7<T &; <'8 `&$=5>% ,<'8 384< T&$ "&$%@ D&4473%T D$3%74' 7519
Related Documents
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks
SAVE OUR EARTH

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!

x